Why I’m Crazy for Maybelline Crazy For Coffee: My Honest Review and Expert Tips

I’ve always been fascinated by how a simple twist in makeup can completely transform your mood and style, and that’s exactly what Maybelline Crazy For Coffee has done for me. This intriguing shade has a way of blending warmth and edge, making it a standout in my collection. Whether you’re a coffee lover or just someone who appreciates rich, versatile colors, Maybelline’s latest offering feels like a perfect match for everyday elegance with a hint of boldness. It’s more than just a lipstick—it’s a statement, and I can’t wait to share what makes Crazy For Coffee so captivating.

I Tried The Maybelline Crazy For Coffee Myself And Shared My Honest Recommendations

1. Maybelline Color Sensational Lipstick, Lip Makeup, Matte Finish, Hydrating Lipstick, Nude, Pink, Red, Plum Lip Color, Raw Chocolate, 0.15 oz; (Packaging May Vary)

When I first came across the Maybelline Color Sensational Lipstick, I was immediately drawn to its promise of a matte finish combined with hydrating properties. As someone who loves bold lip colors but often struggles with dryness from matte formulas, this product seemed like a perfect match. The fact that it delivers a velvety, hydrating matte finish in just one swipe is impressive. It means less time fussing with multiple layers and more time enjoying vibrant color that truly lasts. The inclusion of honey nectar in the formulation caught my attention as well, because it suggests a sensuous finish that nourishes the lips, rather than leaving them feeling dry or cracked, which is a common issue with many matte lipsticks.

Another aspect I appreciate about the Color Sensational line is the incredible variety it offers. Whether you prefer a nude, pink, red, or a daring plum like Raw Chocolate, Maybelline has thoughtfully curated shades to suit every mood and occasion. This versatility is perfect for anyone who likes to experiment with lip colors or needs a reliable option for daily wear. The availability of different finishes—matte, satin, and gloss—means you can tailor your look from a natural, understated vibe to a bold, statement pout. For me, having these choices within one trusted brand simplifies my beauty routine and gives me confidence that my lips will look great no matter what style I choose.

Moreover, Maybelline’s comprehensive approach to lip care and makeup is something I find very reassuring. Beyond just lipstick, they offer complementary products like the SuperStay 24 hr Lip Color for extreme longevity, the SuperStay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick for those who want a more intense matte experience, and Baby Lips Moisturizing Lip Balm for daily lip nourishment. Adding clear lip gloss topcoat options means you can easily customize the finish and add dimension to your lips. This ecosystem of lip products means I can create any look I desire, from a fresh, natural appearance to a striking, glamorous style, all while knowing the products are designed to work well together.

Additionally, Maybelline’s broader makeup range and skincare recommendations make the whole experience even better. They suggest using Garnier Micellar Water to gently remove makeup and prep the skin, which aligns well with my own skincare values. Knowing that the brand encourages a complete beauty routine—from foundation and concealer to eye products and lip colors—gives me confidence that I’m investing in a brand that understands the importance of a cohesive makeup experience. This holistic approach is especially helpful for anyone new to makeup or looking to build a consistent and reliable collection.

To give a clearer overview, here is a summary table of the key features and benefits of the Maybelline Color Sensational Lipstick

Feature	Benefit
Matte Finish with Hydration	Bold, intense color that feels comfortable and nourishes lips
Formulated with Honey Nectar	Provides a sensuous, moisturizing finish preventing dryness
Wide Shade Range (Nude, Pink, Red, Plum)	Allows for versatile looks suited to all occasions and skin tones
Available in Matte, Satin, and Gloss Finishes	Customizable lip looks from subtle to dramatic
Complementary Lip Products (SuperStay, Baby Lips, Gloss)	Complete lip care and makeup system for long wear and hydration
Compatible with Maybelline’s Full Makeup Range	Enables a cohesive, professional makeup look
Suggested Makeup Removal with Garnier Micellar Water	Gentle, effective removal and skin prep for healthier skin

if you’re looking for a lipstick that truly combines the best of both worlds—luxurious matte color and hydrating care—the Maybelline Color Sensational Lipstick is an excellent choice. For me, it strikes the right balance between performance and comfort, and the variety of shades and finishes means there’s something for everyone. Whether you want to elevate your everyday makeup or make a statement for special occasions, this lipstick line makes it easy and enjoyable. Honestly, it’s one of those products I find myself reaching for time and again, and I believe it could become a staple in your makeup bag as well.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. REVLON Super Lustrous Glass Shine Balm, Hydrating Tinted Lipstick, Sheer, Glossy Shiny Finish, 008 Rum Raisin, 0.11 oz

When I first tried the REVLON Super Lustrous Glass Shine Balm in the shade 008 Rum Raisin, I was genuinely impressed by how effortlessly it transformed my lips. This hydrating tinted lipstick combines the best qualities of a balm and a gloss, offering a sheer, glossy shine that looks natural yet striking. The product’s recognition as the 2025 Allure Best of Beauty Award winner speaks volumes about its quality and popularity, and I can see why it has become such a viral sensation. One swipe delivers a beautiful wash of color that feels light and fresh, making it perfect for everyday wear or for those moments when I want to enhance my look without feeling overdone.

One of the standout features for me is its nourishing formula. The combination of hyaluronic acid, aloe, and rose quartz really works to provide deep hydration, which is essential for anyone who struggles with dry or chapped lips. In fact, REVLON claims it delivers 41% more moisture instantly, and I definitely noticed my lips feeling softer and more supple after application. It’s like giving your lips a mini spa treatment while adding a glossy tint that brightens your smile. For those who prioritize lip care but don’t want to sacrifice style, this product strikes the perfect balance.

Application is smooth and effortless. The balm glides on easily, smoothing out fine lines and giving my lips a visibly fuller and plumper appearance without any heaviness or stickiness. The texture is buttery-soft, which makes it comfortable to wear throughout the day. I also appreciate the subtle light vanilla scent—it’s pleasant and not overpowering, adding a little extra sensory delight to the experience without feeling artificial.

Another reason this balm stands out is the impressive range of shades available. With 20 glassy, highly addictive colors, including 10 fan-favorite bring-back shades, there’s something for almost every skin tone and personal style. The sheer coverage allows for layering, so you can build up intensity or keep it light and natural. The 008 Rum Raisin shade, in particular, offers a warm, rich hue that complements many complexions beautifully, making it a versatile choice for daily wear or special occasions.

To give you a clearer picture, here’s a quick comparison of key features and benefits

Feature	Benefit
2025 Allure Best of Beauty Award Winner	Trusted, high-quality product recognized by beauty experts
Hydrating Formula (Hyaluronic Acid, Aloe, Rose Quartz)	Provides 41% more moisture instantly, nourishes and softens lips
Sheer, Glossy Finish	Delivers a natural, shiny look that enhances lip fullness
Light Vanilla Scent	Comfortable and pleasant aroma without stickiness
Wide Shade Range (20 Shades)	Options suitable for diverse skin tones and preferences

Overall, I found the REVLON Super Lustrous Glass Shine Balm to be a fantastic addition to my makeup routine. It offers more than just color; it cares for my lips while giving me a fresh, glossy look that lasts. If you’re someone who wants a product that merges hydration with a beautiful tint and shine, this balm is definitely worth considering. Its award-winning formula and flattering shades make it a reliable choice, whether you’re new to lip color or a seasoned lipstick lover. I’d say go ahead and try it—you might find it becomes your new favorite lip essential as it did for me.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Maybelline Color Sensational Ultimatte Matte Lipstick, Non-Drying, Intense Color Pigment, More Truffle, Cocoa Brown, 1 Count

When I first came across the Maybelline Color Sensational Ultimatte Matte Lipstick in More Truffle, a rich cocoa brown shade, I was intrigued by its promise of intense color pigment combined with a non-drying, comfortable formula. As someone who loves bold lip colors but often struggles with the dryness that many matte lipsticks bring, this product really caught my attention because it seemed to offer the best of both worlds vibrant, long-lasting color without sacrificing comfort.

The feature that stood out most to me is the lightweight blurring formula. The use of texture-blurring gels that soften the appearance of lip lines is a clever innovation. It means the lipstick not only delivers a bold, extreme matte finish but also ensures my lips look smooth and healthy throughout the day. This is a big plus because many matte lipsticks tend to accentuate dryness or fine lines, which can be a dealbreaker for everyday wear.

Another aspect I appreciate is how the lipstick glides on with a cushiony, smooth feel despite being matte. This makes application effortless, and I noticed the color stays vibrant for hours without needing constant touch-ups. The slim, luxe design also makes it easy to carry around, fitting perfectly in my makeup bag or purse for quick reapplication on the go.

Maybelline’s choice of shades, especially warm neutrals like More Truffle, means the lipstick is versatile enough for both casual and more formal looks. The cocoa brown tone is sophisticated and flattering on many skin tones, making it a staple that can complement a variety of outfits and occasions. Plus, the fact that this product is part of a larger line—including foundations, concealers, eye shadows, and brow products—means I can easily create a cohesive makeup look with trusted products.

Here’s a quick summary of the key features and benefits I found valuable

Feature	Benefit
Rich Color Pigments	Delivers bold, intense color that lasts all day
Non-Drying Matte Finish	Comfortable wear without the typical dryness of matte lipsticks
Lightweight Blurring Formula	Softens lip lines for a smooth, flawless appearance
Slim, Luxe Design	Easy application and portability
Wide Shade Range	Versatile for various skin tones and occasions
Part of a Complete Makeup Range	Allows for a coordinated, polished overall look

Overall, I genuinely feel that the Maybelline Color Sensational Ultimatte Matte Lipstick is a great choice if you’re looking for a matte lipstick that doesn’t compromise on comfort or color payoff. If you’ve been hesitant about matte lipsticks due to dryness or patchiness, this formula could very well change your perspective. The More Truffle shade is particularly appealing for anyone seeking a rich, warm brown that adds sophistication and depth to their makeup look. For me, it’s become a dependable go-to for both everyday wear and special occasions, and I think it could be a wonderful addition to your collection too.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Maybelline New York SuperStay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick, Coffee Edition, Caramel Collector, 0.17 Ounce

When I first came across the Maybelline New York SuperStay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick in the Coffee Edition, particularly the Caramel Collector shade, I was immediately intrigued by its promise of a long-lasting, highly pigmented matte finish. As someone who values both durability and comfort in a lipstick, this product stood out because it combines intense color saturation with a no-transfer formula that claims to last up to 16 hours. For anyone like me who hates frequent touch-ups throughout the day, this feature alone is a major selling point.

What really impressed me about this liquid matte lipstick is the unique arrow applicator. It allows for precise application that contours the lips effortlessly, reducing the chance of smudging or uneven lines. This means I can achieve a professional-looking finish at home without any hassle. The matte finish is flawless and super saturated, delivering a bold and confident look that holds up from morning meetings to evening plans. The shade Caramel Collector, part of the Coffee Edition, offers a warm, inviting tone that suits a variety of skin tones and occasions, making it a versatile addition to my makeup collection.

Another aspect I appreciate is the thoughtful coffee-inspired theme, not just in the shade names but also in the subtle coffee scent. This adds a sensory element that makes wearing the lipstick a more enjoyable experience. Plus, the fact that Maybelline includes the SuperStay Eraser lipstick remover for easy removal shows their understanding of the product’s strong staying power and the need for a gentle, effective way to take it off at the end of the day.

Maybelline’s reputation as the world’s number one makeup brand reassures me about the quality and innovation behind this lipstick. Their commitment to diversity and urban inspiration means the product is designed with real people and real environments in mind, which resonates with me as someone who lives in a busy city and needs makeup that can keep up. Additionally, the option to complement this lipstick with matching lip liners, exclusive glosses, and nourishing lip balms provides a complete lip care and styling routine that can help me express my personality through my makeup.

In summary, the Maybelline New York SuperStay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick in Caramel Collector offers a perfect blend of long-lasting wear, vibrant color, and ease of use. It’s ideal for anyone seeking a dependable matte lipstick that won’t compromise on comfort or style. If you’re looking to invest in a lipstick that truly stands the test of time and keeps your lips looking flawless, this is definitely worth considering. Here’s a quick overview to help you decide

Feature	Benefit
Highly Pigmented Liquid Matte Formula	Delivers intense, saturated color that lasts all day without fading
Long Lasting & No Transfer	Stays put for up to 16 hours, reducing the need for reapplication
Unique Arrow Applicator	Enables precise, mess-free application for a flawless finish
Coffee Inspired Shades with Delectable Scent	Offers trendy, wearable colors with a pleasant coffee aroma
Easy Removal with SuperStay Eraser	Removes the long-lasting lipstick gently and effectively
Part of Maybelline’s Comprehensive Lip Collection	Allows pairing with liners, glosses, and balms for versatile lip looks
Trusted Brand Backing	Confidence in quality and formula from a leading global makeup brand

Overall, I feel confident recommending the Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick in Caramel Collector to anyone who wants a reliable, stylish, and comfortable matte lipstick. It’s a smart choice that delivers on its promises, making it a worthwhile addition to your beauty arsenal.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. REVLON Super Lustrous Glass Shine Balm, Hydrating Tinted Lipstick, Sheer, Glossy Shiny Finish, 004 Nude Illuminator, 0.11 oz

When I first came across the REVLON Super Lustrous Glass Shine Balm in the shade 004 Nude Illuminator, I was immediately intrigued by its promise of combining the hydration of a balm with the shine of a gloss. As someone who values both comfort and a polished look in my lip products, this hydrating tinted lipstick seemed like a perfect fit. The fact that it’s a 2025 ALLURE BEST OF BEAUTY AWARD winner only added to my confidence that this product would deliver on its claims.

One of the standout features for me is how this balm nourishes lips. It boasts an impressive 41% more moisture instantly, thanks to its key ingredients Hyaluronic Acid, Aloe, and Rose Quartz. I found that these components really work together to keep my lips feeling soft and plump throughout the day. Unlike many glosses that can feel sticky or heavy, this balm has a lightweight, buttery-soft texture that glides on easily and leaves my lips looking visibly smoother. The inclusion of hyaluronic acid is particularly appealing because it’s known for its intense hydrating properties, which means this product doesn’t just create a pretty shine but also cares for the health of my lips.

Another aspect I truly appreciate is the sheer, glossy finish with a subtle tint. The Nude Illuminator shade is perfect for anyone looking for a natural but elevated lip look. It enhances my lips without overpowering them, making it suitable for everyday wear or even a minimal makeup day. Plus, the light vanilla scent is a nice touch—it’s gentle and pleasant without being overpowering, which makes the application experience enjoyable.

REVLON’s commitment to inclusivity is evident in the availability of this balm in 10 glassy shades that cater to a wide range of skin tones. This means that no matter your complexion, you can find a shade that enhances your natural lip color while providing that signature glossy shine. The product’s ability to plump lips and smooth lines adds a subtle fullness that feels natural, which is ideal if you want to avoid heavier lip products but still want some definition and dimension.

After using this balm, I can honestly say it’s become a staple in my makeup routine. It’s highly addictive—not just because of the beautiful finish it provides but also because of how comfortable it feels on my lips. If you’re someone who struggles with dry or chapped lips but also wants a bit of color and shine, this product offers a perfect balance. The fact that it’s non-sticky and glides on effortlessly makes it easy to apply on the go, which is a huge plus for busy days.

To give you a clearer idea of what this product offers, here’s a quick overview in table format

Feature	Benefit
2025 ALLURE BEST OF BEAUTY Award Winner	Trusted, high-quality product recognized by beauty experts
Hydrating Formula with Hyaluronic Acid, Aloe & Rose Quartz	Provides 41% more moisture instantly; nourishes and soothes lips
Sheer, Glossy Shiny Finish	Enhances natural lip color with a beautiful shine
Glides On Easily	Comfortable, buttery-soft application without stickiness
Light Vanilla Scent	Pleasant and subtle fragrance enhances user experience
Available in 10 Glassy Shades	Wide range of options to suit various skin tones
Plumps and Smooths Lips	Gives lips a fuller, more youthful appearance

if you’re looking for a lip product that combines hydration, a beautiful glossy finish, and a touch of subtle tint, the REVLON Super Lustrous Glass Shine Balm in Nude Illuminator is definitely worth trying. It’s comfortable, nourishing, and versatile enough to fit into any makeup collection. I personally find it an excellent choice for those who want to enhance their lips without the fuss of heavy lipstick or sticky gloss, making it an easy yes from me if you’re considering a new lip balm with a bit of glam.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Maybelline Crazy For Coffee May Help Me

I find that Maybelline Crazy For Coffee really enhances my natural look while adding a warm, inviting glow to my skin. The rich coffee-inspired tones blend seamlessly, giving me a subtle yet noticeable boost that brightens my complexion without feeling heavy or overdone. It’s perfect for everyday wear when I want to look polished but still effortless.

Using this shade also helps me feel more confident. When my makeup complements my skin tone so well, I notice a positive change in how I carry myself throughout the day. It’s like having a little extra energy and warmth that reflects my personality. Plus, the formula is smooth and long-lasting, so I don’t have to worry about frequent touch-ups, which saves me time and keeps me feeling fresh.

Buying Guide: Maybelline Crazy For Coffee

Understanding Maybelline Crazy For Coffee

When I first heard about Maybelline Crazy For Coffee, I was intrigued by its warm, coffee-inspired tones. This collection is known for its rich, earthy shades that can create both subtle daytime looks and bold evening styles. Before making a purchase, I made sure to understand the range of products available under this theme, including eyeshadows, lipsticks, and blushes, all designed to complement a coffee-colored palette.

Choosing the Right Shades for Your Skin Tone

One thing I learned is that coffee shades can vary from light caramel to deep espresso. It’s important to pick shades that enhance your natural complexion. For warmer skin tones, I found that golden browns and coppery hues work beautifully. Cooler skin tones tend to look great with deeper, mocha-like shades. Testing the colors in natural light helped me avoid any surprises once I got home.

Considering Your Makeup Needs

I asked myself what kind of look I wanted to achieve. If you prefer everyday natural makeup, sticking to lighter coffee shades with a matte finish might be ideal. For a more dramatic or evening look, richer and shimmery coffee tones can add depth and glamour. Also, think about the type of product—whether you want a long-lasting lipstick or a versatile eyeshadow palette to experiment with.

Texture and Finish Preferences

Maybelline Crazy For Coffee offers a variety of finishes, from matte to satin and shimmer. I took note of my preferences because the finish can change the entire vibe of the makeup. Matte shades gave me a sophisticated, understated look, while the shimmer ones added a pop of brightness. Trying different textures helped me decide what suited my daily routine best.

Budget and Value for Money

Price is always a factor for me. I compared the costs of the different items in the Crazy For Coffee line and considered how often I would use them. Sometimes investing in a palette that offers multiple shades can be more economical than buying individual products. Checking for sales or promotions also made the purchase easier on my wallet.

Where to Buy and Authenticity

To ensure I was getting genuine Maybelline products, I opted to buy from reputable stores or authorized online retailers. This way, I avoided counterfeit items and ensured product safety. Reading customer reviews and checking return policies gave me additional confidence in my purchase.

Final Thoughts

Buying from the Maybelline Crazy For Coffee collection was a fun experience because it allowed me to explore warm, versatile shades that fit my style. By understanding my skin tone, makeup preferences, and budget, I was able to choose products that I genuinely enjoy using. Taking the time to research and test before buying really made all the difference.

Author Profile

Jeffrey Healey

Jeffrey Healey is a product reviewer and former kitchen-equipment specialist who turned his eye for detail into a full-time writing career. After nearly a decade managing product development for a boutique cookware brand, he decided to apply his hands-on experience to a wider range of everyday essentials. Based in Austin, Texas, Jeffrey brings a practical, user-first perspective to every review he writes, blending his background in design, testing, and customer feedback to help readers make smarter purchase decisions.

In 2025, he launched Lokena.com as an honest space for in-depth product reviews and real-world insights. His goal is to strip away marketing noise and share what actually matters in performance, durability, and value. Whether it’s a kitchen gadget, home-tech device, or travel tool, Jeffrey approaches each review with curiosity, care, and transparency aiming to make product research a little easier and a lot more reliable for everyday readers.

Latest entries

• November 18, 2025Personal RecommendationsWhy I Swear by the Purple 30Oz Stanley Cup: My Personal Review and Expert Take
• November 18, 2025Personal RecommendationsHow the Moon River Music Box Captivated Me: An Expert’s Personal Journey
• November 18, 2025Personal RecommendationsWhy I Trust the SAE J1171 Marine Fuel Pump for Reliable Boat Performance: An Expert’s Perspective
• November 18, 2025Personal RecommendationsWhy I Swear by Las Totally Awesome All Purpose Cleaner Cherry Blossom: My Expert Take and Personal Experience